| John Ryall Mayo | 1854 - 1855 |
| Frederick Greenham | 1855 - 1856 |
| William Bide | 1856 - 1858 |
| Robert Tucker | 1858 - 1860 |
| William Bide | 1860 - 1862 |
| Elias Whitby | 1862 - 1864 |
| Edward Raymond | 1864 - 1867 |
| Joseph Chaffey Moore | 1867 - 1869 |
| James Curtis | 1869 - 1871 |
| Joseph Chaffey Moore | 1871 - 1872 |
| Elias Whitby | 1872 - 1873 |
| James Curtis | 1873 - 1874 |
| John Hill | 1874 - 1876 |
| John Curtis | 1876 - 1878 |
| Elias Lyndall Whitby | 1878 - 1879 |
| Edward Raymond | 1879 - 1880 |
| Jabez Bradford | 1880 - 1882 |
| William Cox | 1882 - 1884 |
| Edwin Hellier | 1884 - 1886 |
| Joseph Chaffey Moore | 1886 - 1887 |
| Ptolemy Samuel Henry Colmer | 1887 - 1889 |
| Herbert William Southcombe | 1889 - 1890 |
| Ptolemy Samuel Henry Colmer | 1890 - 1892 |
| George Wrentmore Gawler | 1892 - 1893 |
| Sidney Watts | 1893 - 1897 |
| Henry Cary Tomkins | 1897 - 1898 |
| John Vincent | 1898 - 1901 |
| Sidney Watts | 1901 - 1902 |
| William Walter Johnson | 1902 - 1904 |
| Henry Stiby | 1904 - 1905 |
| William Alfred Hunt | 1905 - 1906 |
| William Cole | 1906 - 1909 |
| Edmund Damon | 1909 - 1911 |
| John Henry Boll | 1911 - 1912 |
| Norman Buchanan | 1912 - 1916 |
| Edmund Damon | 1916 - 1917 |
| George Henry Gould | 1917 - 1918 |
| William Richard Edwards Mitchelmore | 1918 - 1921 |
| Ernest John Farr | 1921 - 1922 |
| Jabez Matthews | 1922 - 1925 |
| Percival Waddams Petter | 1925 - 1927 |
| Sidney Charles Clothier | 1927 - 1929 |
| William Earl Tucker | 1929 - 1932 |
| Albert Henry John Stroud | 1932 - 1935 |
| Sidney Charles Clothier | 1935 - 1937 |
| Frank Beel | 1937 - 1940 |
| Stanley Duckworth | 1940 - 1943 |
| William Sidney Vosper | 1943 - 1946 |
| Benjamin Dening | 1946 - 1950 |
| Stanley Howard Vincent | 1950 - 1952 |
| William Austin | 1952 - 1954 |
| William Brownhill Hickman | 1954 - 1956 |
| Dorothy Vincent | 1956 - 1957 |
| William John English | 1957 - 1959 |
| Dorothy Vincent | 1959 - 1960 |
| Joseph Patrick Kelly | 1960 - 1962 |
| Charles Edward Hawes | 1962 - 1964 |
| Ivy Seed | 1964 - 1966 |
| Francis Leonard Moon | 1966 - 1968 |
| Fred Stanley Holland | 1968 - 1969 |
| Philip Roydon Cooper | 1969 - 1970 |
| Leonard Escott Hole | 1970 - 1971 |
| Peter Richard Unwin | 1971 - 1972 |
| Hazel Clara Brown | 1972 - 1974 |
| | |
| YEOVIL CHARTER TRUSTEES (1974-1982) Charter Mayors |
| | |
| Kay Heath | 1974 - 1976 |
| James Gardner | 1976 - 1977 |
| John Cruddas | 1977 - 1979 |
| Stanley Oakes | 1979 - 1981 |
| Sydney Harding | 1981 - 1982 |